From Defeat to Victory
Opinions and speak on Northeast India. {Acknowledgement: The title of this blog as some may know is from 'Uncle Bill's' military classic of the same.}
Friday, May 9, 2008
China's border attitude - Whys and hows...
1. Arunachal Pradesh is "South Tibet" extension of the Nyingchi and Shannan prefectures. And its IMPORTANT to annex AP to complete annexation of Tibet into China.
2. Aksai Chin is not as important now with alternative modern communication systems available to Xinxiang province. Maybe we can keep it..maybe...we will return it to India
3. Keep aggressive posturing along the border to impress upon India that we want AP in China.
4. Keep talking to India with a big stick(read nuclear). I suspect the Chinese firmly believe India is weak(They have a reason from 1962). Any sign of India bolstering itself be it the recent nuclear deal with US(though a useless one) makes the Chinese go nuts.
As to how to respond go figure..
Thursday, April 24, 2008
Quotes of Men who did stuff in the NE!
motto of 1st Air Commando Group, WW2; adopted from Orde Charles Wingate, Chindits Commander.
#######################################################################
"I've heard the same story all the way from the States. It's always the same - the Ledo Road can't be built. Too much mud, too much rain, too much malaria. From now on we're forgetting this defeatist spirit. The Ledo Road is going to be built - mud, rain, and malaria be damned."
Colonel Lewis A. Pick, US Army engineer upon arrival in CBI theatre(NE)
#################################################################################
"When You Go Home, Tell Them Of Us And Say, For Their Tomorrow, We Gave Our Today"
The Kohima Epitaph
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
"My uncle is not greater than my country"
Governor of upper Assam and Commander-in-Chief of the Ahom army
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
"I claim we got a hell of a beating. We got run out of Burma and it is humiliating as hell. I think we ought to find out what caused it, go back and retake it. ... The Japanese are not supermen. If we go back properly proportioned and properly equipped we can throw them out."
Gen Joseph Stilwell walking from Maymyo to Imphal by May 20, 1942 in New Delhi
Beyond the Borders - A Reality Check
The situation of NE no 1. the Stilwell road is unlikely to happen because of security fears of India and Burma from insurgent groups and Kachins. The road in India side is NH 153 but Burma side is in very bad shape - just a dirt track! ESCAP will have to fund millions of dollars to make it an international highway.No. 2 the Railway link through Manipur is not happening because of the very bad security experience of India after opening the road through Moreh-Tamu to Kalewa. No 3. The Mizoram to Sittwe port link is running into rough weather because of Chinese interference. They want Sittwe for pumping oil to China. And Bangladesh has refused any transit to NE.The situation is very bleak and grim as usual for us. If you agree I think this is the time to examine ourselves to introspect what we did wrong. It very difficult to survive in the modern world cut-off from all our neighbours without any economic co-operation. But we have to be strong like our forefathers and find a way. We will have to find solutions to our own problems. We cannot expect outsiders to do things for us. Btw its fortunate that we have WW2 history in our home where men from faraway lands came here and turned 'Defeat into Victory'. When I told some American friends about the most amazing 'Stilwell Road' they were very surprised and inspired and want to know more. There are enormous challenges in this region of the world and though I dont like Stallone's way of solving them, I think I still like when John Rambo says "Live for nothing and die for something".
Moving on to Arunachal the situation is still very unclear because of the unsettled boundary issue between India and China. The game of incursions cat and mouse is still going on and this does not do any good to the relations between the two countries notwithstanding the increasing trade volumes. Really it must be tough to be an Arunachalee with such an added burden of psychological pressure.